id summary reporter owner description type status priority milestone component version resolution keywords cc 602 Variables in palette mode related text vdrugeon "1. In the syntax of palette coding, the first for loop uses ""NumPredictedPaletteEntries[ startComp ] < 31"" as one of the conditions to stop the loop. But NumPredictedPaletteEntries is not an array. It is only a variable in the rest of the specification. 2. The variable PredictorPaletteSize is sometimes used as a simple variable, sometimes as an array. At first sight, it seems to be used only with index startComp when it is used as an array though, so that a simple variable may be enough? 3. In 8.4.1 General decoding process for coding units coded in intra prediction mode, is it correct to always invoke the palette process with startComp equal to 0, even for chroma dual tree? At first sight, I would have expected that the process should be called with startComp equal to 1 when treeType is equal to DUAL_TREE_CHROMA, same as is done for calling the palette_coding structure in the syntax. If the current text describes the intended behaviour, why is startComp needed at all as input to the palette process, since it is always equal to 0? Please check! " defect closed minor spec fixed ksuehring bbross XiangLi fbossen jvet@…