Opened 17 months ago
Closed 16 months ago
#1601 closed defect (fixed)
STILL_B_1 / STILL_B_ERICSSON_1 checksum and OPL difference
Reported by: | ksuehring | Owned by: | ksuehring |
---|---|---|---|
Priority: | minor | Milestone: | |
Component: | Conformance | Version: | |
Keywords: | Cc: | ksuehring, fbossen, jvet@… |
Description
Test bitstreams in the FDIS and FDIS_r1 directory are supposed to be the same, except for removal of company names.
It was found though, that in the transition of STILL_B_ERICSSON_1 to STILL_B_1 both YUV MD5 hash and OPL file changed.
The bitstream files are identical and contain five frames. The OPL file of the STILL_B_ERICSSON_1 stream contains all the frames in the stream. The OPL file for STILL_B_1 contains only the first frame. The change for the YUV file looks similar.
The stream is specified as follows:
Test bitstream STILL_B_ERICSSON
Specification: This bitstream tests a Main 10 Still Picture decoder’s capability of decoding the first picture of a bitstream conforming to the Main 10 profile when the first picture of the bitstream is a GDR picture with ph_recovery_poc_cnt equal to 0.
Functional stage: Still picture
Purpose: Check that a Main 10 Still Picture decoder can decode the first picture of a Main 10 bitstream when the first picture of the bitstream is a GDR picture with ph_recovery_poc_cnt equal to 0.
The bitstream is a Main 10 bistream, not a still picture profile as the name may suggest. A multi-profile decoder like VTM cannot determine from the bitstream that it would be expected to only decode the first picture. A Main 10 Still Picture profile bitstream would only be allowed to contain a single picture.
If a Main 10 capable decoder sees a bitstream that is marked as Main 10, it should obviously decode all pictures in the stream. The single frame decoding case seems like a special case for a Main 10 stream being tested with a still picture only decoder. Expecting that behavior as the default seems confusing.
Thus I think the change of OPL and MD5 may be not intentional. For an intentional change, I would also expect the version of the stream to be incremented.
A similar issue seems to exist in STILL444_B_ERICSSON_1 and STILL444_B_1.
Attachments (4)
Change history (12)
comment:1 Changed 17 months ago by adamjw
comment:2 Changed 17 months ago by martin.m.pettersson
Thanks for noticing, Karsten.
I agree, the contents of the zip-files are not supposed to change from the FDIS versions of the conformance streams. The FDIS versions of the STILL_B_ERICSSON_1 and STILL444_B_ERICSSON_1 conformance streams contain .opl and .md5 files for both the full video decode and the decoded first picture. The new FDIS_r versions only contains .opl and .md5 files for the first decoded picture.
Please redo the renaming of the STILL_B_ERICSSON_1 and STILL444_B_ERICSSON_1 conformance streams without changing the content of the files or removing any files.
And yes, the STILL_B_ERICSSON_1 and STILL444_B_ERICSSON_1 conformance streams are Main 10 and Main 10 4:4:4 bitstreams that are used to check the decoder capabilities for Main 10 Still Picture and Main 10 4:4:4 Still Picture decoders, see text below. These conformance streams should of course also be fully decodable by a Main 10 / Main 10 4:4:4 decoder, hence the duplicate .opl and .md5 files.
A.3 Profiles
...
Decoders conforming to the Main 10 Still Picture profile at a specific level of a specific tier shall also be capable of decoding of the first picture of a bitstream when both of the following conditions apply:
- That bitstream is indicated to conform to the Main 10 profile, to conform to a tier that is lower than or equal to the specified tier, and to conform to a level that is not level 15.5 and is lower than or equal to the specified level.
- That picture is an IRAP picture or is a GDR picture with ph_recovery_poc_cnt equal to 0, is in an output layer, and has ph_pic_output_flag equal to 1.
...
Decoders conforming to the Main 10 4:4:4 Still Picture profile at a specific level of a specific tier shall also be capable of decoding of the first picture of a bitstream when both of the following conditions apply:
- That bitstream is indicated to conform to the Main 10 or Main 10 4:4:4 profile, to conform to a tier that is lower than or equal to the specified tier, to conform to a level that is not level 15.5 and is lower than or equal to the specified level.
- That picture is an IRAP picture or is a GDR picture with ph_recovery_poc_cnt equal to 0, is in an output layer, and has ph_pic_output_flag equal to 1.
comment:3 Changed 17 months ago by iole_moccagatta
Karsten,
good catch. Indeed packets in FDIS and FDIS_r1 are supposed to be the same, except for i) removal of company names, and ii) removal of email addresses.
I re-generated STILL_B_1.zip and STILL444_B_1.zip - see attached. Please take a look and let me know if they are OK.
comment:4 Changed 17 months ago by martin.m.pettersson
Thanks Iole,
It all looks good to me except that the STILL_B_1.yuv.md5 and STILL444_B_1.yuv.md5 still have different md5 checksums than STILL_B_ERICSSON_1.yuv.md5 and STILL444_B_ERICSSON_1.yuv.md5. I have attached zip-files where that has been fixed.
comment:5 Changed 17 months ago by iole_moccagatta
Martin,
thanks. Will upload them to dropbox.
comment:6 Changed 16 months ago by iole_moccagatta
The 2 packages are correctly decoded by VTM-20.2 and have been uploaded to /jvet-site/bitstream_exchange/VVC/under_test/VTM-20.2_r1.
I think we can close this ticket.
comment:7 Changed 16 months ago by ksuehring
- Owner set to ksuehring
- Status changed from new to assigned
comment:8 Changed 16 months ago by ksuehring
- Resolution set to fixed
- Status changed from assigned to closed
A similar issue seems to exist in STILL444_B_ERICSSON_1 and STILL444_B_1.