Incorrect conditions for zeroing-out of a quantization matrix element m[ x ][ y ]

[moonmo.koo]

In section 8.7.3 (Scaling process for transform coefficients), the following "NOTE" can be found just below the equation (1142) in VVC spec text (JVET-P2001-vE.docx):

NOTE – A quantization matrix element m[ x ][ y ] can be zeroed out when any of the following conditions is true
- x is greater than 32
- y is greater than 32
- The decoded tu is not coded by default transform mode (i.e. transform type is not equal to 0 ) and x is greater than 16
- The decoded tu is not coded by default transform mode (i.e. transform type is not equal to 0 ) and y is greater than 16

It seems that "greater than 32" and "greater than 16" should be corrected by "greater than or equal to 32" and "greater than or equal to 16", respectively (or, "greater than 31" and "greater than 15"), considering the current MTS zero-out.

[delagrangep]

Agreed.

[bbross]

Thanks for reporting!

This is fixed in JVET-Q2001-v3.